Portage Route Chapter of the Lewis and Clark Trail Alliance
Great Falls, MT
  • Home
  • Events and Speakers
  • About
  • At the Falls
  • Contact Us
  • Blog

Army in Boats -- pt 2

7/25/2022

 
An Army in Boats
Part 2:  East of the Divide - 1805

          The Lewis and Clark Expedition is known as a trek by water from St. Louis to the Pacific Ocean and back, along with a few times the exploring was on land. It is generally understood that the Expedition left Camp Dubois in a keelboat and two pirogues and made their way up the Missouri to the Mandan villages where they wintered.  The next Spring the keelboat was sent back to St. Louis and the Expedition continued on up the Missouri River to where one pirogue was cached.  The other pirogue was cached at the Lower Portage Camp.  The rest of the trip was a mixture of boat and horse travel.  Somewhere along the way during the 1806 return, after splitting into several groups, they got back together on the Missouri and finished the trip to St. Louis in boats. 
          What many people do not realize is the Corps of Discovery made canoes in four different places along their water trail.  They started the trip on the large eastern rivers that required larger boats.  When they reached the upper Missouri, they were on smaller western waterways that called for smaller boats.  Here is where the canoes became useful.
          After the keelboat left for St. Louis from Fort Mandan the Corps of Discovery needed more boats than the two pirogues they had, so men were sent five miles upriver where they had located six cottonwood trees large enough to make dugout canoes from.  When Lewis left winter camp with his men, he had two pirogues and six canoes. 
          All went well until they reached the mouth of the Marias River.  At that place they cached part of their food supplies and other equipment that would not be needed on the journey over the mountains.  With the reduction in “baggage” came a reduction in the number of water craft needed to carry it in.  One of the pirogues was also cached at the Marias. 
          The Corps of Discovery continued on about 50 miles until they encountered the Great Falls of the Missouri.  The other pirogue was cached at the Lower Portage Camp because it was too big and heavy to portage around the waterfalls and it would be too big for the much smaller rivers above the falls.  The collapsible, iron-framed boat had been carried along to replace the pirogues.  It would be light but capable of hauling a large load of men and equipment.  When that boat would not stay afloat, it was discarded.
          Once again, men were sent upriver to where cottonwood trees were found that were adequate for making dugout canoes from.  Two canoes were made at this place which is about eight miles beyond the Upper Portage Camp.  When The Expedition continued their travels toward the western sea, they were using eight canoes.
          The Expedition worked its way up the Missouri River to the Three Forks where the Madison, Gallatin, and Jefferson Rivers join to form the Missouri River.  From the Three Forks they followed the Jefferson since it appeared to go west into the mountains while the other two went in a more southerly direction.
            As they progressed along the upper reaches of the Jefferson River near the mouth of the Big Hole River (Lewis’ Wisdom River), they encountered an area of rapids that gave them particular trouble.  While they were camped drying wet baggage, they cached one of the canoes there since they had used their supplies down to the point they could continue with one less canoe.  Some fifty miles farther up the Jefferson, near its source, the Expedition cached their canoes at Camp Fortunate then traded for horses to cross the Rocky Mountains.


Army in Boats--pt 1

7/16/2022

 
An Army in Boats
Part I:  The Adventure Story
 
          If the purpose of studying history I to learn from the past to help plan for the future, then we must find a way to understand the past history as best we can. We need to see and understand both the good and the bad to enable us to universalize that which will endure the tests of time.  It is relatively easy to understand the events, but to profit from knowing what happened we need to understand why the events happened.
             If we personalize that history, that is make the people involved as understandable as possible we must show them as real people instead of “heroes” placed on high pedestals by society, we will best accomplish our task of learning and better understanding the events of our past.
           The following 5 part article uses a detailed record of canoe counts during the Expedition’s journey to better understand their Journals and the writers.
          By tracking the number of canoes, including when and how they were obtained we can:
  • See that the explorers did not always record many details, including some important ones
  • See the need for several journalists to get a more complete story
  • See journalists were not always objective, but had inherent prejudices
    • These savages made great canoes but had even greater skill on how to use them which gave them freedom to move about their environment
    • Dismal notch as an example
  • See we need to sometimes go beyond what the journalists wrote to get the complete story
    • letters they wrote
    • other writers of their time
    • Toussaint Charbonneau as example
             
          When Jefferson and Lewis were making the initial plans for the journey to explore the Upper Louisiana Purchase, they knew a portage would be needed to go from the headwaters of the Missouri to the headwaters of the Columbia—across the Rocky Mountains—which they calculated would be just a short distance requiring one day to complete.  The boats they would use to travel up the Missouri would be too large and heavy to haul across the portage.
            The solution worked out was to make canoes at Fort Mandan to replace the keelboat that was to return to St. Louis.  Later, the iron framed boat would be assembled to replace the two pirogues since they could not be portaged.
            The iron framed boat would be the primary craft down the Columbia to the Pacific, then back upriver the next Spring.  It would be re-portaged and the Expedition would use it for the trip down the Missouri and home.
            As unexpected events occurred and the plans started unraveling, the two Captains quickly adjusted the plans as needed to get the job done.  Their boats are a good example of their abilities as commanders who were flexible and capable of getting the rest of the Corps to “buy in” to what needed to be done to get the job at hand successfully completed.

Who Were Replaceable?

7/3/2022

 
           Those of us who follow the Lewis and Clark Expedition and its legacy have spent a great deal of time poring over books and articles to learn everything we can about who these brave people where and what they did.  The journey of the Corps of Discovery was a major episode in our American history.
            We have learned that President Jefferson wanted the journey to be made by a military unit that was used to life on the frontier.  We know that several of the men who were destined to become members of the Corps of Discovery were civilians recruited by Clark from the frontiers of Kentucky.
            There must have been some sort of selection criteria since several of the military personnel who made it to Camp Dubois were returned to their units as unacceptable to the Captains.  The only clue we get is that Lewis asked Clark to get a few good hunters.  In my opinion how the selections were made is one of the least understood, yet most important elements of the preparations for the expedition.
            As we read about the early days of life in Camp Dubois, we start to get a better picture of what these men could and could not do.  We find a mix of skills that would be used throughout the journey such as, blacksmiths, carpenters, surveyors, boatmen, hunters, trappers, fishermen, interpreters, and tailor.  Most of the men had some skill in all areas, but each seemed to have something he was best suited for.  But what if for some reason one of the selected men did not go and someone else had been sent in his place?  How much would the overall expedition suffered?  To expand upon that idea, who were replaceable and who were not?
            A person could go through the list of people who participated in the expedition, one by one, to show strengths and weaknesses then make a decision to replace or keep.  However, that would undoubtedly be a waste of time because we really don’t know enough about most of them to justify such an exercise.  Separate the two Captains from the list then, as a group, it can be said they were common men who answered the call.  They were people like you and me who did the best they could, most of the time.  Then, when the expedition was done, they returned to their prior lives of simple, common men.
             The Captains were separated because they both went to continued public life until their deaths.  But that is not to say that they could not have been replaceable.
             I read a book titled The Collected What If, edited by Robert Cowley.  He said “what ifs” are questions bantered about by historians when they are not doing otherwise purposeful research.  These mental gymnastics can from time to time produce some new or different perspective on an aspect of history.  Regardless of outcome they are almost always fun to think about. 
             The question of who was replaceable on the Lewis and Clark Expedition fits very much into the “what if” category. 
             That question is summed up by one of the contributors to Cowley’s book, William H. McNeal who writes on page 827 (of my copy) “So what if Pizzaro had not found potatoes in Peru?  Our world would be radically different for sure, even though no one can say exactly how very different it would be.”

    written by:
    ​Phil Scriver
    ​and others

    Archives

    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.